On Tuesday, he shared ERCOTs tweet. who appoints ercot board of directors - trinayani.org As ERCOT is a 501 (c) (4), a board of directors is the governing force. The board members were not all immediately available for comment or referred reporters to their resignation letters. A CVS Pharmacy in South Austin is lit only by the lights of a parked car. Theyll have to be proactive and smart. Before his appointment, Mr. Lake served as Chairman of the Texas Water Development Board, the states primary water planning and financing agency charged with leading efforts to ensure a secure water future for Texans. Public Counsel for Office of Public Utility Counsel. Three other ERCOT board members also appear to live thousands of miles from Texas. In addition, Vanessa Anesetti-Parra, the market segment director for the independent retail electric provider market segment, will also resign her position as a board member. The ERCOT website biographies prior to being pulled down listed ERCOT Chair Sally Talbert as a former state utility regulator in Michigan. window.googletag.cmd.push(function() { ERCOT will have to change, a lot. Ivey, whose appointment was approved by ERCOT's members but was pending final approval from the PUC, is retired from more than three decades of experience in the utilities industry. Sign up for The Brief, our daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news. }); "ERCOT is an agency of the state, of Texas and what happened this week is a failure not just of ERCOT but of the statewide leadership, state representatives, state senators who didn't do enough to make the necessary structural changes to prevent what took place this week.". Raymond Hopper is another non-native member who lives in Auburn, Maine. ", Statement on resignation of @ERCOT_ISO leadership: pic.twitter.com/kSMw1qTpK5, "When Texans were in desperate need of electricity, ERCOT failed to do its job and Texans were left shivering in their homes without power. Others are appointed by companies and consumers participating in the electricity market, with members representing various power sources. He has advised numerous governments and has been on the ERCOT board since 2015. maybe we shouldnt have deregulated and privatized ERCOT. The vacancies will not immediately be filled. For instance, in most circumstances, it could get very cold in the Panhandle but still be 70 from Waco south. Li Cohen is a social media producer and trending content writer for CBS News. Most recently, he was the president of Consolidated Edison Co. of New York Inc., a subsidiary of Consolidated Edison Inc. Anesetti-Parra oversees Just Energys North American residential and commercial regulatory affairs and compliance division and has two decades of experience in the retail energy sector. Powered by. Theyre gone. As millions of Texans have been without electrical power sometimes for days public outrage has grown. State officials confirmed that they pulled down the photos and biographies of ERCOT board members from the website due to possible safety threats. Dr. Aguilar has served as a President/CEO and on the board level with some of the world's largest engineering and construction firms specializing in clean-energy, power, transportation, real estate, industrial water, and technology start-ups in the United States, Latin America, United Kingdom, Europe, Asia, Africa, and Australia. She has ties to Texas outside of her work with ERCOT. No time to waste. A social media page lists her home as Toronto. eventAction: 'view' window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('impressionViewable', function(event) { Talberg was elected as the chairwoman of ERCOT as a newcomer less than two weeks before the widespread power outages. At its head is Talberg, who lives in Michigan far from the blackouts, officials said. Texas politicians saw electricity deregulation as a better future. Four board members of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) have resigned amid backlash . Mr. Swainsons career includes extensive experience in software, technology, and business management. @ERCOT_ISO Board of Directors elected newcomer @SallyTalberg to a three-year term as its chair and six-year veteran Peter Cramton as its vice chair. [53] Thats a huge area, larger than many whole states, over which most people wont be using a lot of power, so power could be surged to the cold area, which is also larger than many whole states, and which is not as heavily populated. A third of the board of directors that operate the states electrical grid do not appear to live in Texas, and their performance in wake of widespread outages has led to a Dallas-area lawmakers call for change. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), ERCOT announces search for new board of directors after mass - Chron ERCOT manages the flow of power to more than 26 million Texas residents, its website says. Leach also said he was troubled by threats made against ERCOT Board members, as well as ERCOTs decision to pull down the board members names and bios. ERCOT did not immediately respond to CBS News' request for comment. In her law practice, she advised leading companies on complex energy, regulatory, and corporate governance matters. CEO Bill Mangess said in a press conference that cntact information for the Electric Reliability Council of Texas' board of directors will be restored to the council's website next week . 2023 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. ERCOT have removed the names of their board membersfrom their website after allegedly receiving death threats. Between the pandemic, the economy, a brewing border crisis, and now this massive winter disaster, the governor and the legislators have their work cut out for them. As of Tuesday morning, more than 1.37 million people were still without power in Houston, according to the Houston Chronicle. Some of the other members include Terry Bulger, Mark Carpenter, Lori Cobos, Keith Emery and Nick Fehrenbach some of whom do not even remotely hail from a background in energy and power segment. Abbott's claim on Fox News | VERIFY. For one thing, about a third of its members dont even live in Texas. "I doubt you could find an expert anywhere that would say eliminating the independent experts from the ERCOT board was an improvement," Cramton said. What exactly is it? Talberg said in a statement at the time she was excited about the new role. She was elected as chair of the board only days before the power outage. Fifteen directors serve on the ERCOT board, including the four unaffiliated directors, whose resignations will be effective at the end of the meeting Wednesday. Ms. Talberg also has experience with environmental and safety compliance and enforcement for drinking water and wastewater facilities. Records indicate she lives in Williamston, Michigan. ADVERTISEMENT Records show the two top office holders of the 15-member board of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), live out-of-state. Bryan Preston served as chief of staff to Texas Railroad Commissioner Ryan Sitton. "With the right follow through, Texas can lead the nation in investing in infrastructure and emergency preparedness to withstand the effects of severe weather events whether in the form of flooding, drought, extreme temperatures, or hurricanes," the resigning members wrote. Just an FYI, five members of the ERCOT board of directors live out of state. The heads of ERCOT's board of directors don't even live in Texas. We want what is best for ERCOT and for Texas.". }); Mr. Lake was born and raised in Tyler, Texas. For todaygenerators to return, renewable output to increase = increased customer restoration., Leach wrote, Seriously?!?! Completely ridiculous and unacceptable that current ERCOT Board Chair lives in Michigan! he wrote on Twitter. Its not often I underestimate the size of Texas, but I did here. WFAA conducted a 20-minute interview with the CEO of ERCOT Tuesday morning, talking about the current electric crisis in Texas. Hes a veteran, author, and Texan. He served as a versatile executive at NiSource for six years, holding numerous roles, including Chief Operating Officer, Executive Vice President and President of Columbia Gas Group, and Chief Customer Officer. Five ERCOT board members who live outside of Texas to resign I'm frustrated and cannot believe that the board chair of our leading energy decision maker doesn't even live in Texas, but lives in Michigan. Texas has consistently refused to weatherize their energy infrastructure because it doesnt get cold here. We are one of the worlds fastest growing I have friends who are dealing with this and will be dealing with it for a long time after the storm. Talbert failed to return calls or texts by WFAA. Commissioner Talberg previously served as an analyst at the Michigan Public Service Commission, managed enforcement and contested cases at the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality, and advised commissioners at the Public Utility Commission of Texas. Top Salaries Paid to ERCOT Officials Before Texas Storm businesses never again experience power outages on this magnitude, she wrote. More than 4.5 million customers were without power at one point last week. Writer R.G. Records indicate he now lives in Maine. },false) "I cannot imagine how this change could improve resilience to winter storms," Cramton said. The 11-member board consists of eight directors who are appointed by the State of Texas' ERCOT Board Selection Committee and who are required by law to not have fiduciary duty or assets in the electricity market for the ERCOT Region, and three ex officio members: the CEO of ERCOT (non-voting), the Public Counsel of the Office of Public Utility 5 ERCOT board members don't live in Texas, one from Canada Experts, but not people affected by the failure. He holds a bachelors degree in applied science from the University of British Columbia. Innovation Studio. Many, probably most, Texans hadnt heard of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas until this week. "We are ordering an investigation into ERCOT and immediate transparency by ERCOT," he tweeted. ERCOT Chair Sally Talberg lives in Michigan and served on the Michigan Public Service Commission until 2020, according to her ERCOT biography. Three other ERCOT board members also appear to live thousands of miles from Texas. As the agency announced that the power outages would continue till the end of the week, residents did not find it acceptable to live in the dark inside freezing homes for such a long time, especially during a snowstorm situation. pg.acq.push(function() { Ms. England has also served in executive roles in engineering and technology with Texas Instruments, Inc., including Vice President and General Manager of the companys Radio Frequency Identification Division. AUSTIN, Texas The Electric Reliability Council of Texas announced in a Tuesday notice to the Public Utility Commission of Texas that four of its board members will resign effective Wednesday,. Member of Reliability & Markets Committee, Member of Human Resources & Governance Committee. Ms. Heeg is an experienced corporate director and business leader who serves on the board of WhiteWater Midstream, a privately held natural gas infrastructure company. Ms. Talberg holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Environmental and Natural Resources Policy Studies from Michigan State University and a masters degree in Public Affairs from the Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs at the University of Texas-Austin. It just cannot be that way here in the Lone Star State.. Craig Ivey, who was set to fill a vacant position on the board, said in a separate letter that he was withdrawing his candidacy "to avoid becoming a distraction" over his out-of-state residency. Gregg Abbott announced on Tuesday ERCOT reform would be made an emergency item, calling on an investigation of the electrical management company to ensure Texans will never suffer through a power outage of this magnitude again. Its getting buried in a snowstorm which for Texas is just crazy! Three of the resigning board members live in other states, and one lives in another country. Its also cheap and its available in parts of Texas. According to his LinkedIn page, he lives in Del Mar, California. He resides in Florida, according to an ERCOT announcement about his candidacy to the board. It just cannot be that way here in the Lone Star State.. pg.acq.push(function() { },false) Vice Chair Peter Cramton is a professor at the University of Cologne in Germany and the University of Maryland. It gets cold out there, not usually this cold, but cold enough to consider winterizing. Example video title will go here for this video. Bulger lives in Wheaton, Illinois, a Chicago suburb, and Hepper lives in Maine. The resignations will go into effect following a 10 a.m. meeting on Wednesday. A spokesperson tells ABC13 the board and senior leaders were getting threats because of the anger over the widespread power outages. Texans, in turn, are blasting public officials including Former Colorado City Mayor Tim Boyd, and ERCOT, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas. Answer this: What do I say to the elderly couple in my District who havent had power in over 36 hours and are struggling to survive in their 30 home?. }); ERCOT Will Restore Board of Directors' Names to Website - Newsweek Governor Greg Abbott appointed Peter Lake to serve as Chairman of the Public Utility Commission of Texas on April 12, 2021, for a term set to expire on September 1, 2023. pic.twitter.com/9v5eGt18uJ, Sally Talberg (@SallyTalberg) February 9, 2021. Whether you lost power or not, Texans could see higher bills, No, wind and solar power are not the main causes of Texas' power outages despite Gov. Meet the North Texan who has gained worldwide attention for his pancake designs, DFW weather: Warming temps and storm chances this week. As per the ERCOT official website, chairwoman Sally Talberg, who was a former state utility regulator, is now a resident of Michigan. Among the conversations to be had are how much the state should depend on wind power, which did collapse as demand surged but has bounced back, and if were going to depend on wind then why dont we winterize the windmills in West Texas? Amid the power and climate crisis plaguing Texas, Governor Greg Abbott has ordered an investigation into ERCOT, demanding immediate transparency about the situation from them. Ice was also snapping powerlines in untold numbers of places. He was one of the unaffiliated ERCOT board members who mostly served as outside expert voices. hitType: 'event', Cramton, the former ERCOT board member, is also an economics professor at the University of Cologne in Germany and an expert in electricity market design. ERCOT has had a difficult job dealing with this terrible storm, but its public communications have not helped. ga('ads.send', { If the wind turbines are unreliable in these temps then we shouldnt rely on them. Chair of Reliability & Markets Committee, Member of Finance & Audit Committee. His work has emphasized job creation and retention while generating significant value for investors, including public company shareholders, private-equity investors, public sector pensions, and retirement funds. } Just last week, the ERCOT board elected its newest leaders: Sally Talberg and Peter Cramton. DALLAS A third of the board of directors that operate the state's electrical grid do not appear to live in Texas, and their performance in wake of widespread outages has led to a. Texans are getting to know the 50-year-old council and are not liking what theyre learning. Lexi Chuchill and Kiah Collier contributed to this report. Get a 42-inch oscillating fan for 15% off with this deal. "We needed to step in and make sure that we were not going to end up with Texas in a blackout, which could keep folks without power not just some people without power but everyone in our region without power for much, much longer than we believe this event is going to last, as long and as difficult as this event is right now, he said in a statement, reported Dallas News. Other ERCOT board members who records indicate live out-of-state include: WFAA asked ERCOT for their board member contact phone numbers and emails, but did not receive a response. She is the vice president of regulatory and compliance at Just Energy. The legislature is angry. Craig Ivey, who was a candidate to serve on the board, has also rescinded his candidacy, effective Tuesday, to "avoid becoming a distraction." He is a retiree from ISO New England which operates the electrical system in six states. }) Instead of rolling blackouts,more than 4 million people were left without electricity for days. Abbott has repeatedly placed blame on ERCOT over the last week but Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner has pushed back on the accusation that ERCOT is entirely at fault. Before his leadership role with Dynegy, he was CFO of UGI Utilities and CEO of FosterWheeler, a global engineering and construction firm, and COO and CFO of NRG Energy. The state had no respite, no region where demand for power was not surging so it could balance the grid, which it usually does have. Winter storm blackouts plagued Texas in 2011, too. Your water pipes may have frozen and burst, rendering your frigid home uninhabitable. #ERCOT is a world-class grid operator that embraces innovation and competition. Sally Talberg, chairwoman of ERCOT's board of directors, is a former state utility regulator who lives in Michigan, according to her biography on ERCOT's website. Records show the two top office holders of the 15-member board of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), live out-of-state. The lack of preparedness and transparency at ERCOT is unacceptable. Texas power outages: 5 things to know about ERCOT, the nonprofit that "You had the independent voice there to check market participants," Wood said. The Texas House has already approved House Bill 10, which would remove independent outside voices on the ERCOT board and replace them with five political appointees. ", State Sen. Charles Schwertner, R-Georgetown, acknowledged that "having political appointees has pluses and minuses. Mr. Lake graduated with a BA in public policy with a specialization in economics from the University of Chicago, and he earned an MBA from Stanford Universitys Graduate School of Business. There are a total of 16 members on ERCOT's board, which appoints officers who manage the grid manager's day-to-day operations. People who are making literally life and death decisions on behalf of our families and our communities don't even live in the state of Texas, Leach said. But I think there was no impact of the chair or the ERCOT board member directors on the weather or on the decisions we had to make to avoid a catastrophic black out.. ", "Sometimes having a political appointee has the added advantage of understanding the political process" Schwertner said. Rep. Jeff Leach, R-Plano, told WFAA that he was totally shocked to learn a third of the ERCOT Board of Directors lived outside Texas. "Its not an issue with the turbines outright. Mr. Flores is a Texas licensed CPA, who earned his undergraduate degree in accounting from Texas A&M University and his MBA from Houston Baptist University. In a joint letter to the rest of the board, the four unaffiliated directors cited the public concern that board members did not live in the state as the reason for their resignation. She served as a senior consultant at Public Sector Consultants, focusing on energy policy and helping to establish Michigan Saves, an energy efficiency financing organization. ERCOT leadership names removed because of threats "The lack of preparedness and transparency at ERCOT is unacceptable, and I welcome these resignations. Another will be, is it possible to keep a few coal plants in working order just in case another winter like this strikes? ERCOT representatives did not return calls seeking comment, but in a statement it said: "We look forward to working with the Texas Legislature, and we thank the outgoing Board Members for their service.". if(document.querySelector("#adunit")){ This is the cost of not planning ahead," they wrote. Republican Gov. the chair lives in Michigan and the vice chair is an economics prof in Cologne Germany. Dr. Aguilar has a combined understanding of both multi-party negotiations and complex financing structures and on-the-ground challenges of engineering and construction management and safety. Im frustrated and cannot believe that the board chair of our leading energy decision maker doesnt even live in Texas, but lives in Michigan. The board directors wrote that before they resign, they will launch the review of the power crisis. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), Due to concerns about possible safety threats, state officials confirmed that they pulled down most of the ERCOT webpage that revealed photos and biographies of each board member. Dr. Melissa C. Lott, a senior research scholar at The Center on Global Energy Policy at Columbia University SIPA, announced the election of Talberg and Cramton on Twitter. ERCOT officials, during a press conference last week, said it had temporarily removed personal information about the directors from its website because they were experiencing harassment. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), The board members include board chairman Sally Talberg (top left), board vice chairman Peter Crampton (top right), finance and audit committee chairman Terry Bulger (bottom left), and governance committee chairman Raymond Hepper (bottom right). ", Letter here: https://t.co/xcLQOPZYiF #txlege, Cassi Pollock (@cassi_pollock) February 17, 2021. The ERCOT grid operator manages the flow of electric power to more than 26 million Texas customers representing about 90% of the state's electric load, according to its website. Good work, @GovAbbott. }); In addition, Mr. Lake served as Director of Special Projects for VantageCap Partners. document.querySelector("#ads").addEventListener('click',function(){ "Doesn't that undermine the notion of independence of ERCOT? eventAction: 'click_image_ads' The Republican governor released an official statement on Twitter about the same. Since 1930, the Texas grid. Texas didn't learn its lesson | Experts say little has changed with winterization of generators since blackouts of 2011. Amid the crisis situation, it has come to light that five of the fifteen officials serving on ERCOT's (The Electric Reliability Council of Texas) board of directors are non-natives of the state itself. Five board members, including the chair, who do not live in Texas will resign. A PowerOutage.us map and grid shows more than 3.4 million Texas households were without power as of 11 a.m. Wednesday. },false) State Sen. Nathan Johnson, D-Dallas, raised concerns about the bill. ERCOT manages the flow of electric power in Texas and is responsible for ensuring the one independent power grid in the country is up and running as it should. Before retirement, Ms. Heeg managed successful law practices with Reed Smith and Norton Rose Fulbright. I wonder how many people died in the last 2 days because of world class ERCOT? one person wrote on Twitter. document.querySelector("#adunit").addEventListener('click',function(){ Another provision of both chambers' legislation requires all board members to reside in Texas, which would prevent experts like Cramton from sitting on the ERCOT board in the future. At the same time, Peter Cramton was named vice chair. He has also served as Director of Business Development for Lake Ronel Oil Company, where he focused on financial analysis of upstream oil and gas opportunities. RELATED: You've heard a lot about ERCOT lately. "For anybody who's just trying to place the blame on ERCOT, that's not enough. It is critical to learn from this experience and bring about the necessary organizational, market, planning, and oversight changes to protect Texans., READ NEXT: Kathryn Adams Limbaugh Announced Husband Died on The Rush Limbaugh Show, Sally Talberg, ERCOT Chairwoman: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. } Great news. Both it and coal have provided a steady power baseline throughout the storms, though one reactor did have to get taken offline when its water cooling system froze up. A massive blackout in Texas shined a spotlight on a little-known policy: ERCOT officers and directors are not required to live in Texas, and Chairwoman Sally Talberg lives in Michigan. Leach acknowledged that Texas has been through an unprecedented weather event with all 254 Texas counties under a disaster emergency declaration. Before serving in these roles, he was hired by Michael Dell to create and run an enterprise software division within Dell Inc., where he ultimately served as President of the Dell Software Group until its sale in 2016. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), window.adsContainer = {"position2":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Above_Next_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position3":{"code":"Article_Mobile_300x250_ATF_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position4":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position5":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle1_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position6":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle2_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position7":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle3_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position8":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle4_Rel","max_width":300,"max_height":250},"position9":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle5_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position10":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle6_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position11":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle7_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position12":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle8_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position13":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle9_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position14":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle10_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position15":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle11_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250},"position16":{"code":"Article_Mobile_Middle12_Rel","max_width":320,"max_height":250}}